In October of 2005, Lycoming cut the ribbon on both its newest and second oldest building on campus. This 19th-century Williamsport landmark on Basin Street started out as a church and ended up as an auto parts store. Now it has been reborn as The Mary Lindsay Welch Honors Hall.

The Honors Hall houses a multi-use recital hall, offices of United Campus Ministry, the Catholic chaplain, and the Community Service Center. A small Meditation Chapel includes a stained glass window rescued from Old Main.